What are the seven strategies at a glance?
The table shows my illustrative ranges for St. Louis, not quotes or forecasts. Every range is approximate (verify before relying on it), and your lender and CPA set what applies to you.
| # | Strategy | Cash to start | Time per month | Risk level |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | House hacking | $12,000 to $25,000 | 5 to 10 hours | Low to medium |
| 2 | Buy-and-hold rental | $55,000 to $90,000 | 2 to 8 hours | Medium |
| 3 | BRRRR | $60,000 to $100,000 (recycled) | 15 to 30 hours during rehab | Medium to high |
| 4 | Short and mid-term rental | $60,000 to $110,000 | 10 to 20 hours | Medium to high |
| 5 | Fix-and-flip | $70,000 to $120,000 | 20 to 40 hours | High |
| 6 | Multifamily value-add | $120,000 and up | 10 to 20 hours | Medium to high |
| 7 | Passive investing | From the price of one share | Close to zero | Varies by vehicle |
How much cash do I need?
Count only cash you can wire after you keep six months of personal reserves. Equity and retirement accounts do not count.
- Under $30,000: House hacking is the realistic direct-ownership option. An FHA loan at 3.5% down on a duplex can run about $15,000 to $20,000 all-in (approximate; confirm with your lender).
- $30,000 to $80,000: A single-family rental in a lower-priced part of the metro such as Affton, Bevo or south city, or a careful BRRRR with a contractor you trust.
- $80,000 to $150,000: A 2 to 4 unit conventional purchase, a BRRRR with hard money, a flip, or two rentals in different submarkets.
- $150,000 and up: Five-plus unit commercial-loan multifamily or value-add projects.
How much time do I have?
Time often decides the strategy before money does.
- No hours: passive only. A rental is not passive.
- A few hours a month: a rental with professional management (quoted around 8% to 10% of collected rent in St. Louis, approximate; verify before relying on it), or a house hack, since you live there anyway.
- 10 to 20 hours a month: self-managed rentals, mid-term rentals, a stabilized small multifamily.
- Part-time-job hours: a BRRRR during rehab, a flip, or a self-managed short-term rental.
How much risk can I take?
Test it with one scenario: a tenant stops paying in the same month a sewer lateral fails. Sewer repairs on older inner-ring houses are often quoted at about $6,000 to $12,000 (approximate; verify before relying on it). If you can cover both without selling anything, active strategies are open to you. If not, build reserves first or stay passive. St. Louis housing is old, with 1900s to 1960s brick common, so sewer laterals, old wiring and tuckpointing are budget lines to plan for, not surprises.
How do I pick a strategy?
Work through four questions in order.
- Do you own your home? If not, house hacking is worth pricing first. You live next to your tenants, which suits some people and not others.
- Do you have 15 or more flexible hours a week and rehab judgment? If yes, look at BRRRR or flips. If no, keep going.
- Do you want the property to pay you now or build wealth later? Cash flow now points to buy-and-hold in the lower-priced south city and south county zip codes (63116, 63109, 63123 in my working notes) or a mid-term rental near the medical campuses. Wealth later points to appreciation-leaning submarkets such as Maplewood, or multifamily value-add.
- Did every answer wear you out? Then look at passive investing. A steady, boring return you stick with can beat an exciting one you abandon.
What do returns look like in 2026?
Thinner than 2021 content promised. Mid-2026 investor loans were quoted around 7.25% to 7.75% against about 6.40% for owner-occupied loans (verify current rates with your lender). Three illustrative cases:
- A $220,000 Affton single-family renting for $1,750 a month shows a cap rate of about 5% to 6%, depending on which expenses you count. At 25% down and 7.5% money with full expenses, cash flow is roughly breakeven or negative. The buy-and-hold guide shows the work.
- A $325,000 Tower Grove South two-family with $2,900 in total rents shows a cap rate of about 5.5% to 7%, depending on condition and taxes. The 1% City earnings tax can apply to you if you live in the city. Ask your CPA.
- Deals that pencil at 8% cash-on-cash or better on day one exist, but they usually carry condition or block risk.
If a pro-forma shows 12% cash-on-cash with no story attached, the story is in what got left out: maintenance, capital repairs or realistic vacancy.
What are the five failure modes?
The five I see most: underestimating old-house repairs, treating the lender’s approval as your budget, self-managing without systems, buying a block instead of studying the submarket data, and quitting before the compounding starts. Each strategy guide lists its own versions.
Where do I start?
Run any address through the cap rate tool before you get attached to it, then read the guide for the strategy your constraints point to. The first investment property guide covers the acquisition checklist. If you want a second set of eyes on a deal, that is what the investor page is for. Financing questions go to a lender, tax questions to a CPA, and entity, lease and partnership questions to an attorney.