Why does BRRRR fit St. Louis, and where does it go wrong?
St. Louis has a deep supply of dated but solid brick houses, an active estate and wholesale pipeline, and entry prices where the whole cycle can fit in a low six-figure budget. It also stacks three jobs on top of each other: acquisitions, construction management and landlording. First-deal mistakes in any one of them can cost a lot.
What is the BRRRR formula, and what changed in 2026?
The classic target is all-in cost (purchase, rehab and holding) at or below 75% of after-repair value (ARV), because lenders have refinanced about 75% of appraised value on investment properties. In 2026 the limit that bites first is usually the debt service coverage ratio (DSCR), not the loan-to-value ratio. With investor refinance rates quoted around 7.25% to 7.75% (mid-2026; verify with your lender) and many lenders asking for a DSCR of about 1.1 to 1.25, a 75% loan often has a payment the rent cannot carry. Sound deals today often return about 80% to 90% of invested cash rather than all of it (approximate; verify before relying on it), with thin cash flow early on. Underwrite it that way from the start.
What does a worked BRRRR look like?
On the illustrative deal below, the refinance returns most but not all of the cash. The property is a south city single-family. All figures are assumptions for illustration, not a quote or a forecast.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Purchase (estate sale, dated, sound roof and foundation) | $95,000 |
| Rehab | $55,000 |
| Contingency | $8,000 |
| Holding costs (6 months of hard money interest at about 11%, utilities, insurance, taxes) | about $7,500 |
| All-in cost | about $165,500 |
| After-repair value, from renovated sales on similar blocks | $220,000 |
| All-in as a share of ARV | about 75% |
By value, 75% of $220,000 is $165,000. By rent, it works out differently. Rent is $1,650 a month. A $165,000 loan at 7.5% over 30 years has a principal and interest payment near $1,154. Add about $242 for property tax and about $130 for insurance and the payment is about $1,526. Rent divided by payment is about 1.08, below the 1.2 floor many lenders use. A lender sizing to that floor would offer roughly $135,000 to $145,000, so you leave about $20,000 to $30,000 in the deal. You then own a renovated house worth about $220,000 with roughly $75,000 or more in equity (approximate; verify before relying on it), and the rent covers the smaller loan. Run your own version in the cap rate tool before you offer.
How do the five stages work in St. Louis?
Buy. Sources that produce here: estate sales and probate, direct outreach to tired landlords, MLS listings that have sat 45 or more days (the days on market guide shows where), sheriff and tax sales (experienced buyers only), and wholesalers. Verify every wholesaler ARV yourself. Look at south city areas such as Bevo and Princeton Heights, edges of Affton, Lemay and some north county municipalities with strong rent-to-price ratios, and walk each block in person.
Rehab. Renovate to the rental standard of the block. Durable vinyl plank flooring over refinished hardwood and laminate counters over stone keep costs in check. On pre-1978 houses, which is nearly all of them, lead-safe work practices are a federal requirement when you disturb paint. Three St. Louis line items blow budgets: sewer laterals at about $6,000 to $12,000 (scope before you buy), old wiring and 60-amp panels at about $4,000 to $9,000, and tuckpointing at about $3,000 to $15,000 (all approximate; verify before relying on it). Pay contractors on completed milestones, not large deposits, verify license and insurance, and expect your first timeline to run about 1.5 times longer.
Rent. Screen as described in the buy-and-hold guide, with identical written criteria for every applicant, because that is a fair housing requirement. A refinance appraisal usually wants a lease in place.
Refinance. Many lenders want about 6 months of ownership before a cash-out refinance on appraised value, and some DSCR products allow less at a higher price. Line up the refinance lender before you buy. Their DSCR floor, seasoning rule and rate tell you today whether the exit exists.
Repeat. Deal two uses the recycled capital plus what you learned about your contractor, your comps and your own tolerance.
What are the failure modes?
- An optimistic ARV. Using the one flip that overshot instead of the median renovated sale. Every later number inherits the error.
- Ignoring DSCR until refinance day. Model the exit loan at current rates against realistic rent before you offer.
- Contractor roulette. Big deposits, no written scope, no milestone schedule.
- Skipping the sewer scope on a great deal. Sometimes the discount was the lateral.
- Running out of cash mid-rehab. Hard money interest keeps running while you stall. Enter with contingency and reserves.
Who is BRRRR for?
It suits someone with about $60,000 to $100,000 of working capital, 15 or more flexible hours a week during rehab, either construction judgment or a proven contractor, and the patience to hold a thin-cash-flow asset for the equity. If that is not you yet, buy-and-hold has fewer moving parts, and house hacking needs less capital. For deal-level review, see the investor page. Financing is for your lender, taxes for your CPA, and contracts and entity setup for an attorney.