Effective gross income
(Monthly rent × 12) − vacancy + other income = $24,000 − $1,440 = $22,560/yr
Gross potential rent minus expected vacancy losses, plus any non-rent income. This is the realistic income figure, never use 100% occupancy in your underwriting.
Operating expenses
Taxes ($2,800) + Insurance ($1,500) + Mgmt ($1,805) + Maintenance ($1,920) + Capex ($1,440) + Other ($600) = $10,065
All annual operating costs. Critically, operating expenses do NOT include the mortgage payment, that’s a financing cost, calculated separately. This distinction is what makes cap rate comparable across cash and financed deals.
Net Operating Income (NOI)
EGI − Operating expenses = $22,560 − $10,065 = $12,495/yr
NOI is the property’s pure earning power before financing. Two deals with identical NOI but different financing have identical cap rates and different cash-on-cash returns. Sophisticated investors compare NOI first.
Cap rate
NOI ÷ Total acquisition cost = $12,495 ÷ $206,000 = 6.07%
The unlevered return, what the property would return if you bought it all cash. 2026 St. Louis benchmarks: 4-5% (premium inner-ring like Brentwood, Webster), 5-7% (Tower Grove, Maplewood, Affton), 7-10% (south city cash-flow zips like Bevo Mill, Holly Hills). Below 4% rarely makes investment sense outside appreciation plays. Above 10% usually signals risk you haven’t priced.
Annual debt service (financed deals only)
$150,000 loan × 7.5% over 30 yr = $12,587/yr P&I
Total annual mortgage payments. The standard amortization formula: M = L × [r(1+r)ⁿ] / [(1+r)ⁿ − 1], where L = loan, r = monthly rate, n = total payments. Multiplied by 12 for annual.
DSCR (Debt Service Coverage Ratio)
NOI ÷ Annual debt service = $12,495 ÷ $12,587 = 0.99
How many times NOI covers your annual mortgage payment. DSCR lenders typically require 1.15-1.25 minimum, below that, they won’t fund. Above 1.4, you have meaningful margin of safety. DSCR is the single most important metric for investor-loan qualification in 2026.
Cash flow
NOI − Annual debt service = $12,495 − $12,587 = −$92/yr (−$8/mo)
What lands in your pocket each year after operating expenses AND mortgage. Negative cash flow means you’re paying out of pocket monthly, sometimes acceptable for appreciation plays, never acceptable as a long-term plan.
Cash-on-cash return
Annual cash flow ÷ Total cash invested = −$92 ÷ $56,000 = −0.16%
The leveraged return on the cash you actually put in. Cash invested = down payment + closing + initial rehab. 2026 St. Louis benchmarks: 4-8% (typical buy-and-hold), 8-12% (well-bought cash-flow deal), 12%+ (BRRRR or significant value-add). Negative or single-digit returns mean reconsider the deal.
The four wealth-building levers
Cap rate and cash-on-cash capture only ONE of four wealth-building levers in real estate. The full picture includes:
1. Cash flow (what we just calculated), money in pocket monthly
2. Appreciation: varies by block and by year, and is never guaranteed
3. Mortgage principal paydown, equity builds whether or not the price moves (about $1,400/yr in year one on a $150K loan at 7.5%)
4. Tax depreciation shield, ~$5,500/yr of paper losses on a $200K residential property (27.5-year straight-line)
These add to your total return, but only the cash flow is in hand each month, and none of it is guaranteed. That is why cap rate alone should not decide a deal.