What are the four ways a rental makes money?
Only one of them is monthly cash flow. The four are cash flow, principal paydown, appreciation and tax treatment.
- Cash flow is what is left after everything: payment, vacancy, repairs, reserves, management. With investor loans quoted around 7.25% to 7.75% in mid-2026 (verify with your lender), a quality St. Louis single-family often shows thin or negative cash flow once you budget every expense.
- Principal paydown is the part of each payment that reduces the loan. It is contractual and grows each year, but at current rates it is smaller in year one than many spreadsheets show.
- Appreciation is not guaranteed. I have used 3% to 4% a year as a long-run planning assumption for St. Louis (an assumption, not a forecast).
- Tax treatment can include depreciation, deductible expenses and 1031 exchanges. Your CPA decides how these apply to you.
What does a worked buy-and-hold look like?
On the illustrative deal below, the property is roughly breakeven to negative on cash and pays you through paydown and appreciation. The property is an Affton single-family brick ranch, 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths, priced at $220,000. All figures are assumptions, not a quote or forecast.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Down payment (25%) | $55,000 |
| Loan at 7.5% | $165,000 |
| Principal and interest | about $1,154 a month |
| Rent | $1,750 a month |
| Property tax | about $202 a month |
| Insurance | about $130 a month |
| Vacancy (5%) | about $88 a month |
| Maintenance and repair reserve (12%) | about $210 a month |
| Management (9%) | about $158 a month |
| Operating costs before the loan payment | about $788 a month |
Net operating income is about $11,500 a year, a cap rate of about 5.2%. After the loan payment, cash flow is about negative $192 a month with professional management. Self-managed it is closer to zero or slightly positive. Year-one principal paydown is about $1,500. If the house appreciates 3.5%, that is about $7,700. Together, in that scenario, year one is roughly $6,900 on $55,000 invested, about 12%, before tax effects. Appreciation is an assumption, not a promise. Buying 5% to 8% under asking after 40 or more days on market is findable and improves the picture. This is why I show worked math instead of adjectives: anyone promising large monthly checks at current rates on a quality submarket deserves a second look. Test your own address in the cap rate tool.
Where is the cash-flow band in St. Louis?
Lower entry prices and higher cap rates show up in Bevo, Princeton Heights, Lemay, edges of Affton, parts of south city (63116, 63109 and 63123 broadly) and some north county municipalities. My notes show cap rates of 7% or more are findable there (approximate; verify before relying on it), with more management work and more block-by-block judgment. A common investor mix is one cash-flow property and one appreciation property.
Should I self-manage or hire a manager?
Self-manage if you are local, own one to three doors, have a handyman, plumber and electrician you can call, and can enforce a late-fee policy. Hire a manager if you are remote, scaling past three or four doors, or know you will put off hard conversations. Management is quoted around 8% to 10% of collected rent plus leasing fees (approximate; verify before relying on it), and I would audit any manager’s statements quarterly.
Screening is the whole business. Write your criteria down, such as income as a multiple of rent, credit and eviction history, and prior landlord references, and apply them the same way to every applicant. That consistency is a fair housing requirement, and an attorney can review your written policy.
What St. Louis rules and costs should I plan for?
- Occupancy permits and rental licensing. The City of St. Louis requires occupancy permits and inspections per tenancy. Many county municipalities, including University City, Maplewood and Ferguson, run their own rental programs, while unincorporated areas such as Affton are lighter touch. Check before you buy, because it changes turnover cost and timing.
- Old-house repairs. Sewer laterals (about $6,000 to $12,000), tuckpointing, flat roof sections and galvanized supply lines. Scope the sewer at purchase and reserve 10% to 12% of rent for repairs on pre-1960 houses (approximate; verify before relying on it).
- City vs. county. The City’s 1% earnings tax can apply to a city resident, and property tax bills differ by address in both the City and the County. Neither is better, they are different products. Compare with the property tax tool.
- Landlord law. Missouri has no rent control, and eviction follows a set procedure. Follow the procedure exactly and confirm current law with an attorney.
What are the failure modes?
- Underwriting with the lender’s numbers instead of operating numbers. Approval math ignores vacancy, repairs and management.
- Buying the pro-forma rent. Verify with comparable leases.
- No repair reserve on 1920s brick.
- Letting deferred maintenance turn small invoices into large ones.
- Selling in year three. Selling costs, which I have seen quoted around 8% (approximate; verify before relying on it), plus interrupted compounding can turn a good hold into a mediocre trade.
Who is this for?
It fits someone with about $55,000 to $90,000 to deploy, a few hours a month or the willingness to pay for management, and a ten-year horizon. Start with the first investment property guide. To walk blocks with someone who will say "not this one" out loud, see the investor page. Loan terms are your lender’s call, tax is your CPA’s, and leases and entities are your attorney’s.