What is the difference between a short-term and a mid-term rental?
Short-term rentals (STR) are stays under 30 days, usually 1 to 7 nights, booked on platforms like Airbnb, VRBO and Booking.com and priced nightly. They bring the highest revenue per night with the most turnover, cleaning cost and regulatory exposure. Mid-term rentals (MTR) are stays of 30 days or more, listed on platforms like Furnished Finder, Zillow, Facebook groups and corporate housing sites, and priced monthly. They bring lower revenue per night, less turnover and more predictable income. Some operators run STR in busy months (May through October in my notes) and MTR in slower months, which takes more skill to manage.
What are the St. Louis short-term rental rules?
Rules changed in 2024 through 2026 and keep changing, so verify before you buy.
City of St. Louis. A short-term rental permit is required through the Building Division, with an annual fee and an inspection. Some areas have special restrictions. Owner-occupied rentals are treated differently from non-owner-occupied ones. The rules have changed more than once since 2023.
St. Louis County. Each municipality sets its own rules. Some prohibit short-term rentals in single-family zoning, some require owner-occupancy, and some require permits and a business license. Call the specific city before purchase.
Condos and HOAs. Association documents often prohibit short-term rentals even where the city allows them, and some set minimum lease lengths of 30, 60 or 90 days. Read the covenants first.
Mid-term rentals. Stays of 30 days or more are often treated as leases rather than transient lodging, which reduces many short-term restrictions. Confirm how the municipality and your association treat them.
What does a mid-term rental pencil out to?
On this illustrative deal, a mid-term rental loses money. The property is a renovated 2 bedroom, 2 bath unit in the Central West End, asking $325,000 and bought at $310,000. All figures are assumptions, not a quote or forecast.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Down payment (25%) | $77,500 |
| Closing costs | $9,300 |
| Furnishing | $22,000 |
| Initial reserves | $8,000 |
| Cash invested | $116,800 |
| Monthly rate | $2,650 |
| Occupancy | 80% |
| Annual gross income | $25,440 |
Annual costs, self-managed:
| Cost | Per year |
|---|---|
| Mortgage principal and interest ($232,500 at 7.25%, 30 years) | $19,032 |
| Property tax | $4,100 |
| Insurance (short-term rental policy) | $1,950 |
| Utilities | $3,600 |
| Internet and cable | $1,440 |
| Cleaning between stays | $1,800 |
| Furniture replacement reserve | $1,500 |
| Total | $33,422 |
Income of $25,440 against costs of $33,422 leaves about negative $7,982 a year when self-managed. A manager at about 10% of revenue adds about $2,500. For comparison, long-term rent on the same unit at $1,850 a month is $22,200 a year gross, so mid-term rent is higher but not by enough to cover the added costs.
What improves the picture: buying 5% to 10% below retail, doing some of the renovation work yourself, self-managing, and having furnishings already in place. At a purchase near $275,000, self-managed, with furnishing in place, the same revenue could show a small positive result (illustrative; verify before relying on it). Run your own version in the cap rate tool.
Where do short and mid-term rentals work in St. Louis?
Demand follows events, visitors and employers. Check the permit status of each address.
Better short-term candidates in my notes: - Soulard (63104): Mardi Gras and brewery visitors, walkable restaurants and bars, strong nightly rates October through March. - Lafayette Square (63104): historic houses, Lafayette Park and events. - Central West End (63108): hospital visitors and Forest Park events, with demand through the year. - Downtown: Cardinals and Blues games and conventions, with seasonality tied to the schedule.
Better mid-term candidates: - Central West End: near the BJC and Washington University medical campus, the largest source of mid-term demand in my notes. - Maplewood: walkable, with a short drive to the medical campuses. - Brentwood: a commute to the medical campuses. - Tower Grove South: neighborhood character and walkability. - The Hill (63110): a restaurant cluster close to Forest Park.
Harder fits: Webster Groves and Kirkwood, which are mostly single-family zoning with restrictions to check, and most of West County (Chesterfield, Ballwin), which is suburban single-family and farther from the medical campuses.
What are the five biggest failure modes?
- Buying without verifying legality. HOA documents or a municipal code can end the plan after you have bought furniture. Before purchase, read the HOA documents, call the permit office, confirm zoning and ask about enforcement.
- Underestimating management. Short-term rentals are a hospitality business: cleaning every stay, guest messages around the clock and reviews that affect visibility. Plan for 10 to 20 hours a week yourself or a specialist manager, often quoted around 15% to 25% of revenue (approximate; verify before relying on it).
- Insurance gaps. A standard homeowner policy may not cover rental activity, and a claim can be denied. Specialized policies are often quoted around $1,500 to $2,500 a year. Disclose all rental use to an insurance broker.
- Seasonality. In my notes May through October produces about 70% of annual revenue (approximate; verify before relying on it). Underwrite on a lower average than your peak months and hold cash for slow ones.
- Rule changes. An ordinance can change your business model. Keep a backup plan of mid-term or long-term rental for every property, and watch city council agendas.