How do Tower Grove South and Maplewood compare side by side?

Tower Grove South is lower priced with a lower property tax rate and higher cap rates; Maplewood has a different school district and no city earnings tax. Figures are approximate (verify before relying on it).

Factor Tower Grove South Maplewood
Median sale price (listing data, early 2026) $325,000 $450,000
City earnings tax 1% (City of St. Louis) None (St. Louis County)
School district (named as a fact) St. Louis Public Schools Maplewood Richmond Heights School District
Predominant housing 1900s to 1920s brick singles and two- to four-family flats 1900s to 1940s mix
Walkable area South Grand and Tower Grove Park Manchester Road
Commute to downtown St. Louis about 8 min about 11 min
Rental cap rate range about 5.5% to 7% about 4% to 5.5%

For school information, check each district’s website and the Missouri DESE report card for current data.

Where does Tower Grove South come out ahead?

Tower Grove South has the lower price and the park. The median is about $125,000 lower for a similar housing product. On a $350,000 home that is about $1,855 a year. Tower Grove Park covers 289 acres of 19th-century park land within walking distance of much of the neighborhood. South Grand holds a deep mix of restaurants, bars and small shops, and the drive downtown is about 8 minutes.

Where does Maplewood come out ahead?

Maplewood has no city earnings tax and generally larger lots. City of St. Louis residents pay the 1% earnings tax, and Maplewood sits in St. Louis County, which does not charge it. Ask your CPA how it applies to your income. Lots in Maplewood tend to be larger than many Tower Grove South lots, which are often about 30 feet wide. Maplewood’s streets also have less commercial pass-through than the busiest Tower Grove South blocks.

How do I choose between them?

Choose Tower Grove South if price, the park and the property tax rate matter most to you. Choose Maplewood if you want to avoid the city earnings tax or want a larger lot. Because the school districts differ, check each district’s site and the Missouri DESE report card, and look at current sold comps for the block you are considering.

What do the two have in common?

Both have older brick housing that needs a repair budget. I see $30,000 to $100,000 for older homes in my working notes (approximate; verify before relying on it). Both have walkable commercial corridors, and both have tighter street parking than the suburbs. Long-run price movement in both has been moderate, and past movement is not a promise.

What does the investor lens look like?

Tower Grove South has the higher cap rates; Maplewood has the higher purchase prices and lower cap rates. In Tower Grove South, purchase prices of about $200,000 to $300,000 and rents of about $1,600 to $2,000 a month sit behind the 5.5% to 7% range. In Maplewood, prices of about $400,000 to $500,000 and rents of about $2,000 to $2,500 sit behind 4% to 5.5% (all approximate; verify before relying on it). Active rehab inventory in Tower Grove South can suit a BRRRR plan, but read the BRRRR guide first, because refinance rules change. This is not investment, tax or legal advice: your lender, CPA and attorney decide those questions. Test any address in the cap rate tool.