How do Affton and Crestwood compare side by side?
Affton has the lower price and lower rate; Crestwood has its own city government and a newer redevelopment. Figures are approximate (verify before relying on it).
| Factor | Affton | Crestwood |
|---|---|---|
| Median sale price (listing data, early 2026) | $285,000 | $325,000 |
| Jurisdiction | Unincorporated St. Louis County | City of Crestwood |
| School district (named as a fact) | Affton (part Bayless) | Lindbergh School District |
| Median home age | built 1955 | built 1960 |
| Predominant housing | 1950s to 1970s ranch and split-level | 1950s to 1970s ranch and two-story |
| Commute to downtown St. Louis | about 18 min | about 20 min |
For school information, check each district’s website and the Missouri DESE report card for current data.
Where does Affton come out ahead?
Affton has the lower price and the lower tax rate. The median is about $40,000 lower, and on a $300,000 home the tax is about $3,300 a year, against about $5,550 on the same value at the Webster Groves rate. Because Affton is unincorporated, there is no municipal property tax layer, and St. Louis County provides police, roads and library service. Affton also tends to have more active listings at a given time, since it covers more area.
Where does Crestwood come out ahead?
Crestwood has its own city government and a redevelopment project. As an incorporated city, Crestwood runs its own police, parks and recreation programs and snow removal. My notes describe the redevelopment of the former Crestwood Plaza mall site as mixed use with new retail; check the city’s site for current status. Some Crestwood streets near Sappington Road are more walkable than most Affton streets. Crestwood is served by the Lindbergh School District, so check its site and the Missouri DESE report card.
How do I choose between them?
Choose Affton if the lowest entry price and tax bill matter most and you are comfortable with an unincorporated area. Choose Crestwood if you want a municipal government, a few more walkable pockets and the Lindbergh district, and you can budget for the higher price. Compare actual tax bills on the specific houses with the property tax tool.
What do the two have in common?
Both are lower-priced St. Louis County markets with mid-century housing. Housing is mostly smaller 1950s to 1970s houses, with less period detail than pre-war brick but usually a lighter repair list. Both are 18 to 20 minutes from downtown and both are more car-dependent than inner-ring towns like Webster Groves, Brentwood and Maplewood. Long-run price movement has been steady rather than fast, and past movement is not a promise.
What does the investor lens look like?
Both work for buy-and-hold with a cash-flow focus, and neither supports BRRRR at scale. I see cap rates of about 5% to 6.5% in Affton and about 5% to 6% in Crestwood (approximate; verify before relying on it). Affton has some small multifamily and single-family rentals. Crestwood has fewer listings. Lower after-repair values leave little room for a refinance that returns your capital, so read the BRRRR guide before you plan around it. This is not investment, tax or legal advice: your lender, CPA and attorney decide those questions.