How do Webster Groves and Kirkwood compare side by side?

Webster Groves has the higher median price and rate; Kirkwood has more land area and a rail station. Median sale price, days on market and tax rates below are approximate (verify before relying on it).

Factor Webster Groves Kirkwood
Median sale price (MARIS, Q1 2026) $561,000 $495,000
School district (named as a fact) Webster Groves School District Kirkwood R-VII School District
Median days on market (MARIS, Q1 2026) 5 days 8 days
Walkable downtowns 2 (Old Webster, Old Orchard) 1 (Downtown Kirkwood)
Land area 5.9 sq mi 9.0 sq mi
Commute to downtown St. Louis about 14 min about 18 min
Amtrak station No Yes
Median home age built 1935 built 1948

For school information, check each district’s website and the Missouri DESE report card for current data.

Where does Webster Groves come out ahead?

Webster Groves has two walkable downtowns and a wider mix of housing styles. Old Webster and Old Orchard each have their own commercial core, so dinner, coffee and errands are on foot from many addresses. The housing mix runs from Tudor houses in Tuxedo Park to arts-and-crafts bungalows in Old Webster to 1950s houses in South Webster. Kirkwood’s stock is more uniform, mostly 1940s through 1960s houses. Homes also sell a little faster in Webster Groves, at a median of 5 days against 8 (MARIS, Q1 2026, approximate), so expect to compete for inventory.

Where does Kirkwood come out ahead?

Kirkwood costs less per square foot, carries a lower tax rate in my figures and has more land. A 2,400 square foot house runs about $625,000 to $725,000 in Webster Groves and about $550,000 to $650,000 in Kirkwood (approximate; verify before relying on it). On a $500,000 home the tax difference is about $1,150 a year, roughly $9,250 against $8,100. Kirkwood’s 9.0 square miles also allow bigger lots on average. The Kirkwood station is on the Texas Eagle and Missouri River Runner routes, which matters if you ride Amtrak.

How do I choose between them?

Pick Webster Groves if walkability to more than one downtown and variety in architecture rank high for you. Pick Kirkwood if price per square foot, the annual tax bill, lot size or the train station rank higher. In practice the decision usually comes down to a specific street and house, so I suggest touring both on the same day.

What do the two have in common?

They share a commute, an older housing stock and a high tax bill relative to the county. Both sit 14 to 18 minutes from downtown, both have walkable downtowns, and both have houses that need the usual old-house work: sewer laterals, electrical, plaster. Both also carry effective tax rates well above the St. Louis County figure I use for comparison. The two towns meet each year in the Webster-Kirkwood Turkey Day football game, often described as one of the oldest continuing high school rivalries in the country.

What does the investor lens look like?

Both are appreciation-first markets, not cash-flow markets. I see stabilized rental cap rates of about 3.5% to 4.5% in both (approximate; verify before relying on it), so these are long-hold plays. Kirkwood usually has the lower entry cost. Financing and tax treatment are for your lender and CPA to decide, and this page is not investment, tax or legal advice. For the math on a specific address, use the cap rate tool.