How do they compare?
| FHA | Conventional | |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum down payment | 3.5% with a 580 score or higher | 3% for eligible first-time buyers |
| Credit | More forgiving | Better pricing as the score rises |
| Mortgage insurance | An upfront premium plus an annual premium. On minimum-down loans the annual premium usually stays for the life of the loan | Private mortgage insurance, removable once you have enough equity |
| Appraisal | Checks value and FHA minimum property standards | Checks value; condition matters less unless it affects safety or value |
| Works with MHDC First Place | Yes | Yes, on the HFA conventional products |
What does an FHA appraiser flag on an older house?
These come up often on St. Louis houses built before 1978:
- Peeling or chipping paint, inside or out, including garages and trim
- A roof with little life left or active leaks
- Missing handrails on stairs
- Broken windows, exposed wiring, utilities that are off at the time of the appraisal
- Standing water or structural concerns in the basement
A flagged item is not a denial. It is a repair that has to be finished and re-inspected before closing. Who does the repair is a contract question, so raise it in the offer if you can see the issue at the showing.
Which one fits which buyer?
- Lower credit score, small down payment. FHA is often the cheaper payment.
- Stronger credit. Conventional usually wins over time because the mortgage insurance ends.
- A house that needs work. Ask about an FHA 203(k) or a conventional renovation loan, which fold repairs into the mortgage.
- Competing offers. Some sellers prefer conventional because of the appraisal. A clean inspection plan and a strong pre-approval narrow that gap.
What should I do first?
Have one lender price both loans on the same day at the same price. Compare the monthly payment, the cash to close and what the payment looks like in year six, not just the rate.
What is the next step?
Text me at (314) 348-5331. I will tell you what I would expect an appraiser to flag on the house you are looking at. I reply within 24 hours.