How do cash buyers price an offer?

Most use some version of the 70% rule: offer = ARV x about 70% - estimated repairs. The percentage runs higher on clean properties and lower on heavy distress; the range I see cited is generally 65% to 80% of ARV (approximate; verify before relying on it).

Worked example (hypothetical): a $250,000 home in fair condition.

The buyer is a business, and their offer has to leave them a profit after repairs, holding costs and resale. That is why the number sits below market.

There is also a second type, the iBuyer, which buys better-condition houses for resale and charges fees. iBuyers have had limited activity in the St. Louis market, so your realistic cash options are generally local investors. Confirm what is active when you ask.

What does listing actually net?

It depends mainly on the sale price and costs, and commission is the largest item. Here is an illustrative structure for a house listed around $260,000 that sells at about 95% of list:

Item Amount
Sale price (95% of a $260K list) $247,000
Title fees, attorney, transfer (seller side) -$1,500
Owner’s title insurance (sometimes the seller pays) -$1,400
Pre-listing prep (paint, cleaning, photos) -$2,000
Repairs negotiated after inspection -$3,000
Net before commission about $239,100

Commission comes out of that number. It is negotiable, and it is set in the listing agreement, so ask any agent to put your actual figure on paper. If you agree to pay part of the buyer’s closing costs, which is more common in slower markets, subtract that as well.

Closing costs are usually split in practice: the buyer pays loan-related fees, and the seller pays seller-side fees. The split is negotiable.

How do the two paths compare?

Here is the same $250,000 house, fair condition, no major issues. Commission is left as a variable.

Cash offer List with an agent
Time from deciding to cash in hand about 7 to 21 days about 60 to 90 days
Repairs required None Often a few thousand dollars of touch-ups
Showings One walkthrough Several to a couple dozen
Commission None Negotiable; set in the listing agreement
Seller-side closing costs Often paid by the buyer Several thousand dollars
Sale price (illustration) about $170,000 about $247,000
Net before commission (illustration) about $170,000 about $239,100

The difference is the discount you pay for skipping the listing process. Get both numbers for your own address, not an illustration.

When does a cash offer make sense?

It makes sense when the open market is not a realistic option or when time is worth more than the discount.

  1. Heavy deferred maintenance you cannot or will not fund. A house needing major foundation, roof, HVAC and plumbing work may not appeal to buyers using conventional financing. A cash buyer may be your only realistic path.
  2. Probate, divorce or an inheritance with several decision makers. If siblings live in three states, the coordination cost of repairs and showings is real. See selling an inherited home in St. Louis.
  3. A tenant-occupied house with eviction or non-payment problems. A buyer who takes it "tenants and all" removes the legal work from your plate. Missouri eviction takes time and court costs.
  4. Foreclosure pressure. If a sale date is close, speed has real value, and a normal listing might not close in time.
  5. An out-of-state owner. Managing repairs, showings and closing from far away can outweigh the listing premium.

When is a cash offer the wrong move?

It is usually the wrong move when the house is in good shape and you have time.

  1. A habitable home in a fast-selling neighborhood. If the market is doing the work, as in Webster Groves, Kirkwood or Maplewood, a listing is likely to outperform a cash offer by a wide margin. See days on market by neighborhood.
  2. You want convenience and have time. Convenience has a price. Many sellers who say they just want to avoid showings change their mind when they see the net difference in dollars.
  3. The house has features a cash formula does not pay for. Acreage, historic character and recent renovations can add to an open-market price. A cash buyer’s formula is condition-based.
  4. You can wait 60 to 90 days. If you have the time, the market can reward you for it.

How do I evaluate a specific cash offer?

Run four steps before you answer.

  1. Get a market analysis (CMA) from a local agent. It is free from me and has no obligation. It tells you the likely list price.
  2. Subtract the commission you negotiate and your estimated closing costs from that price. That is your estimated traditional-sale net.
  3. Compare it with the cash offer.
  4. Divide the gap by the hours of work and the weeks of carrying cost you would save. That tells you what you are paying for your time. It is worth it for some sellers and not for others.

Want the numbers on your own house? Request a home value estimate or book a consultation.

Are there options in between?

Yes, a few.

What are the red flags with cash buyers?

Watch for five things.

To see either number as net proceeds, use the seller net calculator.